While I haven't been to Bimini in my own boat, I have boated all over the Caribbean, and some of the world. I have been to many of the islands and out on the waters. I wouldn't put Bimini or even Hawaii on a bucket list, I would rather fly and charter a boat that can show me more. Lake Powell however, can't be fully seen or enjoyed from a tour. It is in my opinion, the top bucket list item of any boater. It just is far and away more impressive than just another island. I have scuba dove on the Indians, the Rhone, Great Dog, Roatan, Bermuda, Nassau, Bonaire, Little Cayman, Cozumel, Maui, and Belize. Bimini is just the closest to FL, it isn't the most amazing, and none of those, aside from Hawaii, are even in the same discussion as Lake Powell. Once you see it for even a day, your going to be scheduling your next bucket list item.