This is my second HOA and the last one I participate in.
Board member in the last one.
The HOA is basically created by dumb lawyers with no logic to protect the developer while they are building and selling the community. So the first buyer doesn't paint house pink and park 45 foot RV. All that stuff can deter future homeowners.
Example of one of the laws we have:
You can't have permanent basketball hoop, only portable one and after kids done playing it should be stored in garage.
So what that means is a kid should pull out the hoop from garage, fill the base with water, play for half an hour, drain the base, and wheel it into garage. I can tell you even I can't wheel that thing into garage by myself. No logic.
I would prefer professionally installed permanent hoop with condition that homeowner should maintain it with no rust or broken parts.
Normal board can ammend the rules but that is a painful expensive process.
Anyway, what I learned is that HOA can't even enforce their rules even through HOA management company. Like what can they do? The street belongs to county (unless HOA is gated) so it is county rules not HOA rules. Only way to tow you is if your tags are expired, BUT if you keep the car with expired tags on your property county can't tow it.
We had people bring RVs and car that were out of state and sitting for months. Concerned citizens complained, but nothing HOA could do since no one knows even who the owner is
What HOA can do is send you letters with violations, but that is about it. Even if HOA sends you a fine you can contest it and judge will throw it out.
And HOA will try to avoid court since it cost them money too.
This is how MOST HOAs work.
But than there is Columbia MD Association, they are one of the biggest HOAs in the country, they have their own police, fitness clubs, and a ton of other facilities. From what I hear they fine you - you pay them.