Came across a really nice website a few days ago -
www.bestcigarprices.com I've noticed that with this site, you MUST use the click-through's on the website, or else you'll end up seeing a different price, and possibly paying more than their best price. I'm not a fan of this, but I noticed it when looking to add to my cart after my comparisons, and searched directly for each of the cigars listed below - an example is the Tatiana, a direct look shows $94/box, while the flavored cigar specials click-through link shows it can be found for $14/box less than that price. Either price is lower than CI, but it shouldn't show two different prices on the same site, not sure if it fixes this anomaly in the shopping cart prior to placing your order.
As with any online site, it'll depend on what you're looking at, but here's 4 items I was looking at, and the price differences (these are all box prices)
BC = best cigar prices, CI = cigars international
Rocky Patel Vintage 2003 Sixty - BC=$177, CI=$217
Tatiana Mocha Stobona - BC=$80, CI=$100
Nub Cameroon 460 - BC=$90, CI=$135 Cigars International throws in a 10-pack sampler, but they're CLEARLY rolling the cost of the sampler into the box price.
Perdomo Lot 23 Gordito Connecticut - BC=$133, CI=$133
Drew Estate Java Mint "the 58" - BC=$203, CI=$194 Cigars International throws in a 5-pack Java Maduro Robusto for that price, better price AND 5 free!
I'm sure there's some manufacturer limitations on pricing for these guys, as evidenced by the Perdomo's and the Drew Estate's, but the HUGE price difference of the other 3 I was looking at is enough for me to look at this newfound website before I order.