thank you for the feedback. I have 2 seasons down and have dramatically improved my docking skills. I'm on a river and have a good bit of kids on the boat. if it makes it easier and safer i am intrigued but also don't want to waste money. I do have two engines. any thoughts on my scenario? thanks!!
I won't argue yes/no/maybe, that's up to you to decide. Your situation is what I often deal with. On the LAKE, I don't really find them necessary, but they offer more control when picking up a downed skier/tuber/boarder. Can this be done without them? Certainly. Will you get better at this over time? Most definitely. Can accidents happen, even WITH fins and/or experience? Of course. All of that is to say - you do what would make you most comfortable. Would you be kicking yourself if you wanted to go the experience route and save the money on fins, and something happens? Sure. Is it likely to happen? Meh, shrug, whatever "who knows" thing you want to use here, apply it. What's your comfort level with where you're at right now, what's your willingness for gambling/risk/potential, what would benefit you overall as far as others/wife/kid being able to get better QUICKER at this. See what I'm saying? NOBODY here can assess your situation and say "don't bother" or "DEFINITELY, YOU NEED THEM NO MATTER WHAT!!!1ONE!oMg!".
@FSH 210 Sport posted the videos of the girls spinning that big swine in that narrow channel. I have a similar situation, every time, that I deal with when docking. NOBODY in the creek I'm on spins their boat, even though I've got the biggest boat on the creek. They've all got single-motor pontoons, where I have twins and can spin my boat on a dime - I have a VERY shielded channel with zero current at any time, barring tornadoes! LOL
I also frequently boat upriver from the lake I'm on. My fins are a godsend on the river. It was for this reason alone that I ended up taking the plunge to get my fins. Piers are packed in, the current is quite strong in several spots where we stop off, and even with experience, there's times where I would consider having someone get off with dock lines and pull me into position. Generally, this is early in the season when the river is moving much faster, but after adding my fins, it's easily accomplished. Can I get there with more experience without them? Sure. Did this speed up the process for me? Without a doubt. Would I add them to a new boat for MY experience? Again, without a doubt - for MY needs.
I'm not towing someone up and down the river, we're simply moving from place to place, pulling in, stopping for cocktails and music, and moving on to the next spot to do it all again. I tie up to piers a lot. Is your boating the same? Bet not. Is EVERY place on the river I stop at, the same experience? Nope, some are wildly different.
Having had them for a while, I can say that there is a dollar amount that I wouldn't be willing to spend on them, as I don't view them as a foolproof fix, but for what they've done for me, they were worth the money I spent on them. With time, every person gains experience with their boat, which would make it easier down the road to steer your boat. If you have them now, you might skip them on your next boat, if you feel more comfortable,
depending on your boating experience and typical usage.
Similar to the video of those girls, our creek is about 30' wide in front of my pier. If I go down to the end of the creek, there's an area carved out that's 40-50' wide for boats to turn around, and the neighbors or any visitors go down there to turn their boats around. My father-in-law couldn't spin his 16' SeaRay around on two separate occasions without tagging his prop once, then his bow, and never did it again. He had dozens of years more experience than I did, but a single motor, and not a lot of practice doing what I do.
@WiskyDan can attest to my creek, he wasn't comfortable spinning his 24' Yamaha in the same spot. Take whatever I said for what free advice is worth, and here's a pic of what I deal with. Fins didn't make this any easier, as I feel I could spin any boat on a dime and park it here, but I didn't add my fins for this, I added them for my usage on the river. I think at some point this upcoming year, I'm gonna have the wife get some pics to show just what these boats can do