Alright, looking to see if anyone has advice for one of my crew. She applied for a passport renewal (actually just a name update for married name) the first week of March, just before COVID shut everything down. Normally that would of been more than enough time for processing, but COVID screwed it up as with many things. US Passport processing operations resumed June 11, but as of yet she doesn't have her passport in hand. Based on some others in online forums who submitted renewal applications just before her, there's a decent chance she'll get it back just in time for this trip, but it'll be very tight. At this time there is no expedited processing service available unless its a proven life or death situation.
From everything I've found online Bahamas now requires a passport for entry, even by private vessel, unless you're on a round-trip cruise, which apparently has some exemptions. ~3 years ago it appears you could get in with other forms of ID if arriving and departing by private boat, but that seems to have gone away around 2018. Per the U.S. CBP website re-entry into the US by sea appears to be allowed by a Real-ID compliant driver's license, which she can get, but that doesn't help if the Bahamas won't let her enter in the first place.
Obviously having a passport is ideal for many reasons, from avoiding hassle to accommodating an emergency situation, but is anyone aware of an alternative for entry into the Bahamas? I hate to leave her and her husband behind, and we've considered cancelling entirely if they can't go, but hoping there's another option.